3 (621)

Broken Promises: Chief Joseph Surrenders the Nez Perce On October 5, 1877, as cold winds swept across the Bear Paw Mountains of northern Montana, a tired but resolute man stepped forward from a beleaguered encampment. Chief Joseph of the Nez Perce, his face marked by the exhaustion of a 1,170-mile flight, approached General Nelson A. Miles and surrendered. His brief but powerful words would be remembered for generations: “From where the sun now stands, I will fight no more forever.” The Nez Perce, or Nimíipuu (“The People”), had lived for centuries across the rich plateaus and river valleys of what is now Idaho, Oregon, and Washington. Skilled horsemen and adept diplomats, they maintained largely peaceful relations with white explorers and settlers, even aiding Lewis and Clark during their expedition in 1805. But as American settlement surged westward, the pressures on their homeland intensified. Hinmatóowyalahtq̓it, known to history as Chief Joseph, was born around 1840 in the Wallowa Valley of northeastern Oregon. His father, Old Joseph, had signed a treaty with the United States in 1855 that recognized a vast Nez Perce homeland of about 7.7 million acres. That agreement was soon undermined. The discovery of gold in the region brought a rush of settlers and mounting federal pressure to reduce the reservation. A new treaty in 1863 slashed the Nez Perce territory by more than 90 percent, confining them to a fraction of their ancestral land. Old Joseph refused to sign, insisting that his people would not abandon the Wallowa Valley. When Old Joseph died in 1871, leadership passed to his son, who continued to pursue peace through negotiation. Yet by the mid-1870s, U.S. officials were demanding the relocation of all Nez Perce—treaty signers and non-signers alike—onto the smaller Idaho reservation. The situation exploded in June 1877, when a group of young warriors, furious over years of broken promises and violence, attacked nearby settlements, killing several settlers. Joseph and other leaders understood that retribution would be swift and overwhelming. Facing annihilation, they resolved to flee north toward Canada, where they hoped to join Sitting Bull and the Lakota, who had found refuge there after the Battle of the Little Bighorn. Thus began one of the most extraordinary fighting retreats in American history. Roughly 750 Nez Perce—men, women, children, and elders—undertook a desperate trek of more than 1,100 miles through some of the most rugged terrain in the West. Pursued by thousands of U.S. soldiers from several converging columns, they repeatedly outmaneuvered their pursuers and fought them to costly stalemates. The campaign was marked by a series of dramatic battles and skirmishes. At White Bird Canyon in June, the Nez Perce decisively defeated U.S. forces in the opening engagement. At the Battle of the Clearwater in July, they fought a fierce rearguard action before withdrawing eastward. The bloodiest clash came in August at the Battle of Big Hole in Montana Territory, where an American surprise attack inflicted heavy losses, including many women and children, but failed to stop their advance. Time and again, the Nez Perce displayed tactical brilliance, exploiting their deep knowledge of the land and maintaining discipline even under relentless pressure. Their humane treatment of prisoners and civilians alike won them widespread admiration, including from some of the soldiers sent to capture them. But their ordeal was taking a toll. Weeks of fighting, starvation, and exposure sapped their strength. In early October, just 40 miles from the Canadian border, they were intercepted by fresh troops under General Miles, who had coordinated with General Oliver O. Howard’s pursuing column. Surrounded and outnumbered in the Bear Paw Mountains, the Nez Perce endured a grueling five-day siege amid freezing temperatures and dwindling supplies. At last, recognizing that continued resistance meant certain death for his people, Chief Joseph surrendered on October 5. His extemporaneous speech, recorded later by an interpreter, captured both his exhaustion and the depth of his people’s suffering. Although the final line is the most quoted, the full speech mourned the dead, pleaded for the survival of the living, and condemned the injustices his people had endured. The U.S. government promised that the Nez Perce would be allowed to return to their homeland, but those promises were broken. Instead, they were forcibly relocated first to a reservation in Indian Territory (present-day Oklahoma), where many died from disease and the harsh climate, including Joseph’s young daughter. Years later, survivors were moved again to Washington Territory. Chief Joseph devoted the rest of his life to advocating for his people’s return to the Wallowa Valley. He met with President Rutherford B. Hayes in 1879 and spoke before audiences in Washington, D.C., in 1897, but his appeals were consistently rejected. Chief Joseph died on September 21, 1904, on the Colville Reservation in northeastern Washington. The reservation doctor wrote that he had died “of a broken heart.” His life and words have since become enduring symbols of dignity, perseverance, and resistance against injustice. The Nez Perce War was among the last of the Indian Wars, a poignant coda to decades of conflict born from U.S. expansion and broken treaties. It exposed the deep injustices of federal policy toward Native peoples while revealing the extraordinary resilience and humanity of those who resisted. Nearly 150 years later, the story of Chief Joseph and his people remains a powerful testament to endurance in the face of overwhelming odds and a reminder of the enduring struggle for justice and sovereignty. The closing decades of the nineteenth century marked a decisive phase in America’s westward expansion, a movement driven by population growth, economic ambition, and a powerful ideology of national destiny. The Homestead Act of 1862 had unleashed a flood of settlers, promising free land to anyone willing to farm it for five years. The discovery of gold in territories like Idaho (1860), Montana (1862), and the Black Hills (1874) accelerated migration even further, drawing thousands into regions long inhabited by Native nations. These settlers brought with them demands for land, infrastructure, and protection, pressures that fueled aggressive federal policies toward Indigenous peoples. The belief in “Manifest Destiny”—the notion that the United States was divinely ordained to spread across the continent—shaped both public opinion and government action, often justifying violent displacement and broken treaties as the cost of progress. At the same time, structural and political forces transformed the balance of power in the West. The completion of the transcontinental railroad in 1869 revolutionized movement and communication, enabling the rapid deployment of troops, settlers, and supplies deep into Indigenous lands. Following the Civil War, many Union veterans were reassigned to frontier duty, bringing with them military experience, weaponry, and strategies honed in a brutal conflict. Federal policy hardened as well: the Indian Appropriations Act of 1871 ended the recognition of Native nations as sovereign entities, paving the way for unilateral decisions about land and governance. By the mid-1870s, after conflicts like Red Cloud’s War (1866–68) and the Great Sioux War (1876–77), the reservation system had become central to U.S. policy. Yet a growing public unease with the violence of conquest—fueled by reports of massacres and the eloquence of leaders like Chief Joseph—signaled a subtle shift in public opinion. The Nez Perce War unfolded against this backdrop of expansionist zeal, military power, legal coercion, and an emerging national conscience reckoning with the cost of America’s westward ambitions. Chief Joseph’s widely quoted surrender speech was transcribed by an interpreter after the event, and while the famous final line is authentic, historians caution that the full version we know today may have been shaped in part by translation and later publication. The Nez Perce were renowned horse breeders whose selective practices produced the Appaloosa, a distinctive and enduring breed prized for its stamina and spotted coat. During their 1,170-mile flight, the Nez Perce crossed through territories that would later become four U.S. states—Oregon, Washington, Idaho, and Montana—and even briefly entered what was then the Canadian North-West Territories. Chief Joseph was only one among several key leaders during the campaign. Others—including Looking Glass, White Bird, Toohoolhoolzote, and Ollokot (Joseph’s brother)—were instrumental in planning strategies, negotiating decisions, and leading warriors. The site of the 1877 surrender near the Bear Paw Mountains is now part of the Nez Perce National Historical Park and is preserved as the Bear Paw Battlefield, a memorial to the courage and suffering of the Nez Perce people.