Drag to reposition your photo
Dubby1776

Dubby1776

Male. Lives in Pennsylvania, United States.
About Me
Just a GWOT vet angry and disgusted by the very apparent fall of a once great nation.
Dubby1776
Dubby1776

Wall Comment

WaldoJPeabody
Gentle Friend , Gentle Friend , All Gentle Friends. Come play with me. Proposed: Congress can pass any dang law it want's to Constitution be damned. True or False?
    • 1
    1 person likes this.
    1
    ,  reacted this
    WaldoJPeabody
    Take your time formulating your answers, I'm to a nap.
    • August 2, 2021
    Reverend2022
    True
    • August 3, 2021
    WaldoJPeabody
    So, you're saying that Congress can take away our guns despite the protections afforded us by the Second and Tenth Amendments..
    • August 3, 2021
    Dubby1776
    Yes, Congress can pass any law it wants regardless of the constitution. However, according to the constitution any law passed by the Congress that directly violates the bill of rights is null and void. The issue is getting a non corrupt judicial system to overturn the law.
    • August 3, 2021
    WaldoJPeabody
    Gentle Friends and , you are both correct, to a point. Reverend2022, perhaps you could expound a bit on your answer Dubby, you analysis is a bit off, Congress can pass any law it wants, without regards to the Bill of Rights and without Judicial Review. This is enshrined in ... View More
    • August 3, 2021
    Dubby1776
    Article 5
    • August 3, 2021
    WaldoJPeabody
    Try Article 1 Section 8 ( I'm not trying to annoy you with this little game, I'm trying to piss you off, you'll remember better)
    • August 3, 2021
    Dubby1776
    Marbury vs. Madison. This is the precedent set in a court case allowing any laws contrary to the constitution as null and void.
    • August 3, 2021
    WaldoJPeabody
    Agreed, But there's a special carve out in Article 1 Section 8 Paragraph 17 "To exercise exclusive Legislation in all Cases whatsoever, over such District............. " So, Congress can pass any law they want without being in conflict with the Constitution. Than, the trick is to get ever... View More
    • August 3, 2021
    Reverend2022
    My friend, Congress can pass any bill it wants, we have an admitted Marxist dictator holding America by the throat, by way of force they would attempt to disarm the population which would result in armed violence, we do not have a Congress with a back bone and would turn their backs to save themselv... View More
    • August 3, 2021
    WaldoJPeabody
    Gentle Friend, you are struggling for an answer, Everything you say is irrelevant to the question. Congress can pass any law they want, for any purpose, regardless. Where is this enshrined in the Constitution? (By the way, this also plays into your question on the Income Tax so bear... View More
    • August 3, 2021